Tuesday, December 18, 2012



Chapter Three-(2013 series of articles)
NOTES for Breeders Cup, New Zealand Yearling Sales, Champion Sires


2011 – Filly & Mares Turf -Prize money=$2,381,000 -Nov 4, 2011

1….7 furlongs…1m23.47…..won by 1 ¼, head.
2….There are some very good race fillies here.
-----------------------------Musical Romance…15wins19p$3,140,200
-----------------------------Switch……………..10wins$2,498,200
-----------------------------Her Smile………….4w$427,860
-----------------------------Pomeroy’s Pistol…..5w$643,100
-----------------------------Turbulent Descent…13w$2,099,100

Fin Position----Horse---- Level-------Close--------Bal-----Blue--Chains
1-MUSICAL ROMAN’--15.125**4--4x5**1=---55**4--4**4=--655**3
2---SWITCH--------------19.406**1--4x5**1=----63**2--8**1---675**2
3---HER SMILE----------18.070**2--5x7**5-----62**3--7**2---726**1
4--POMEROYS PIST’---17.391**3--4x5**1=---37**5--5**3---627**5
5-TURBULENT DESC’-14.578**5--4x5**1=---84**1--4**4=--628**4

Four of these fillies had a nice 4x5 basic first cross. The 2nd, 3rd and 4th
Placed fillies had very nice high levels of line-breeding. The enigma
is the winning filly which has lower line-breeding level and a dam that has several
good principles, but 4 parts of it’s pedigree with possible inaccuracies based on
 known principles, and the sire has basic principles which would work, but
 several others are missing which complicates the assessment of  the winning
 filly Musical Romance.
Fin Position----Horse-----Intro-----Fem4-----Match-----F4------3Gen
1-MUSICAL ROMAN’--11**4=---52**4------95**3---19**2---5.07**4
2---SWITCH--------------14**1=---45**5-----111**2---16**3---5.33**3
3---HER SMILE----------13**3----94**1-----156**1….30**1--9.60**1
4---POMEROYS PIST’-14**1=---75**3------76**5----12**4=-4.73**5
5-TURBULENT DESC’-11**4=--79**2------81**4….12**4=--7.53**2

2nd and 3rd placed fillies again measure up extremely well here.

Fin Position----Horse-----5Gen-----TMale-----TFemale-----AMale-----
1-MUSICAL ROMAN’--7.14**5------31**1=-----18**4-----10.29**4
2---SWITCH--------------7.38**4-------30**3=-----13**5----11.61**1
3---HER SMILE----------7.43**3------31**1=------21**3-----9.65**5
4---POMEROYS PIST’--8.27**1------30**3=------23**1----11.45**2
5-TURBULENT DESC’-8.22**2------29**5--------22**2----10.74**3

The 4th and 5th placed fillies which were good winners, also showed up
very well on the above principles.

Fin Position----Horse----- AFemale-----DamW-----DamS----DamSW---
1-MUSICAL ROMAN’---4.23**4---------6**4------23**3-------9**2
2---SWITCH---------------3.39**5--------21**1=----28**1------13**1
3---HER SMILE-----------5.45**2--------21**1=----10**5-------2**5
4---POMEROYS PIST’---5.35**3-------16**3------27**2-------3**3=
5-TURBULENT DESC’--5.97**1---------5**5------14**4-------3**3=

All 5 fillies showed impressive levels of selection and numbers for
each of these principles, and allied to extremely good ancestry, it
is clear why these fillies were contesting a high class, valuable race.


Fin Position----Horse------ Pre%--------15G-----------Ped/SW
1-MUSICAL ROMAN’----33**5-------54**3--------414/661=1075**5
2---SWITCH----------------69**2-------50**4---------836/943=1779**2
3---HER SMILE------------66**3------55**2----------672/848=1520**3
4---POMEROYS PIST’----61**4------40**5-------1123/1194=2317**1
5-TURBULENT DESC’---85**1-------70**1---------744/675=1419**4

Having a quick look at the pedigree of Turbulent Descent, we notice she
has won 13 races and earned $2,099,100. She ran 5th in this race and was
fourth in the numbers of SW her first 31 sires sired in total. Sources vary, and
  each week the total can change, but it does give some kind of
comparison, and when the pedigree is checked, the stallions in the pedigree
 become more meaningful.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The 744 SW in her sire’s pedigree look something like this…
Congrats-6, APIndy-140, Seattle Slew-114, Mr Prospector-192,
 BoldReasoning-10, Secretariat-57, Raise a native-78, Northern Dancer-147.

The 675 SW in her dam’s pedigree look something like this..
Forestry-42, Storm Cat-180, Seeking The Gold-92, Storm Bird-63,
Pleasant Colony-78, Mr Prospector-192, Slew o’Gold-28.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I did a few hundred of these Breeders Cup pedigrees, and after adding
up all the SW out to 5 generations,  I did a check with the totals to
4 generations which was much quicker, and in over 90% of the cases
there was no change in the order of the total for the horses being checked.
 Will save a lot of time in the future.

SUMMARY.

Except for the winning filly, Musical Romance, the Breeding Principles
Got the 2nd and 3rd grouped OK, and the 4th and 5th grouped OK.

1 comment:

  1. "The enigma is the winning filly which has lower line-breeding level and a dam that has several good principles, but 4 parts of it’s pedigree with possible inaccuracies based on known principles, and the sire has basic principles which would work, but several others are missing which complicates the assessment of the winning filly Musical Romance."

    Are you saying that the pedigrees of horses in her background are fraudulent (inaccurate)? Do you have physical evidence, like DNA or blood work, to back that up? Or are you just saying that the pedigree does not conform with what you expect from your hypothesis? If so, your hypothesis may need a bit of modification so that it fits with experimental results better (the scientific method), instead of seeming to call into question the accuracy of the American Stud Book. Delve a bit into US regional breeding, especially Florida, which has produced some of the best horses of the last half-century (Dr. Fager, In Reality, Affirmed, etc.) from regional bloodlines.

    Ann Ferland

    ReplyDelete